Project Sherlock

Mathematics

Foundations & Logic

What mathematics rests on, and the limits of what it can prove about itself.

13 topics · 27 curated works

Topics

Reading in Foundations & Logic

27

A way in

  1. Start here

    No prior grounding assumed.

    Gödel's Proof

    Ernest Nagel & James R. Newman · 1958

    Walks a general reader through Gödel's argument that any consistent system strong enough for arithmetic contains truths it cannot prove.

    +3 more at this level

  2. Then

    Assumes you know the vocabulary.

    The Mathematical Analysis of Logic

    George Boole · 1847

    Recasts logical reasoning as an algebra of classes obeying arithmetic-like laws, treating deductive inference as a calculation to be checked rather…

    +8 more at this level

  3. Go deeper

    Primary sources and full treatments.

    On Computable Numbers, with an Application to the Entscheidungsproblem

    Alan Turing · 1936

    Defines the universal machine and proves the halting problem undecidable — the founding document of computer science.

    +13 more at this level

12 of 27 works

Book1958

Gödel's Proof

Ernest Nagel & James R. Newman

Walks a general reader through Gödel's argument that any consistent system strong enough for arithmetic contains truths it cannot prove.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Essay1998

Constructive Mathematics

Douglas Bridges

Argues mathematics should only assert existence where an object can in principle be exhibited or computed, and shows how much of analysis survives when that constraint replaces the law of excluded middle.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Video2021

Math's Fundamental Flaw

Derek Muller (Veritasium)

Traces the route from Cantor's diagonal argument through Godel's incompleteness theorems to Turing's halting problem, arguing they are three faces of one limit on formal systems.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Essay2008

The Axiom of Choice

John L. Bell

Lays out the equivalents of the axiom of choice, including Zorn's Lemma and the well-ordering theorem, and the paradoxical consequences, such as Banach-Tarski, that made it controversial even after its independence from the other axioms was proved.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Essay2008

The Development of Proof Theory

Jan von Plato

Recounts proof theory from Hilbert's program for proving consistency by finitary means through Gentzen's natural deduction and sequent calculus, treating the field's central results as an answer to a foundational crisis rather than a purely technical exercise.

link checked 17 Sept 2026

In order written

1847 – 2021
  1. 1910Principia MathematicaAlfred North Whitehead & Bertrand Russell
  2. 1945General Theory of Natural EquivalencesSamuel Eilenberg & Saunders Mac Lane
  3. 1958Gödel's ProofErnest Nagel & James R. Newman
  4. 1961Non-standard AnalysisAbraham Robinson
  5. 1967Foundations of Constructive AnalysisErrett Bishop
  6. 1998Constructive MathematicsDouglas Bridges
  7. 1999Subsystems of Second Order ArithmeticStephen G. Simpson
  8. 2008The Axiom of ChoiceJohn L. Bell
  9. 2014Set TheoryJoan Bagaria
  10. 2016Model TheoryLou van den Dries and C. Ward Henson
  11. 2021Math's Fundamental FlawDerek Muller (Veritasium)

Elsewhere in Mathematics