Project Sherlock

Philosophy

Logic

The formal structure of valid inference — deduction, predicate and modal logic, and the fallacies and paradoxes testing them.

10 topics · 18 curated works

Topics

Reading in Logic

18

A way in

  1. Start here

    No prior grounding assumed.

    Elementary Lessons in Logic

    W. Stanley Jevons · 1870

    A worked introduction to both deductive and inductive reasoning for readers with no background, built around graduated exercises rather than theory…

    +5 more at this level

  2. Then

    Assumes you know the vocabulary.

    Prior Analytics

    Aristotle · 350 BCE

    Introduces the syllogism, cataloguing the argument-forms that guarantee a true conclusion from true premises and founding formal deductive logic.

    +3 more at this level

  3. Go deeper

    Primary sources and full treatments.

    Elements of Logic

    Richard Whately · 1826

    A systematic logic textbook whose treatment of fallacies of ambiguity, begging the question and irrelevant conclusion became the standard…

    +7 more at this level

12 of 18 works

Book1870

Elementary Lessons in Logic

W. Stanley Jevons

A worked introduction to both deductive and inductive reasoning for readers with no background, built around graduated exercises rather than theory taught for its own sake.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Book1886

The Game of Logic

Lewis Carroll

Teaches syllogistic deduction as a board game played with counters on a diagram, arguing valid inference is a mechanical procedure anyone can learn to perform correctly.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Paper1895

What the Tortoise Said to Achilles

Lewis Carroll

A regress argument: accepting a valid inference's premises never logically forces accepting its conclusion, because the license to draw the inference can always be demanded as a further premise.

3 pageslink checked 17 Sept 2026
Book1896

Symbolic Logic

Lewis Carroll

Works through propositional inference using diagrams and puzzles, treating logic as a game of elimination rather than a set of rules to memorise.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Essay1996

Paraconsistent Logic

Graham Priest, Koji Tanaka & Zach Weber

Surveys logics in which a contradiction no longer entails every proposition, arguing that inconsistency and outright logical explosion are two different things that classical logic wrongly identifies.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Essay2021

Argument and Argumentation

Catarina Dutilh Novaes

Surveys what makes something an argument at all and how the deductive, dialectical and rhetorical models of argument quality pull apart once real disagreement is at stake.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Book1930

Straight and Crooked Thinking

Robert H. Thouless

Names and classifies the dishonest argumentative tricks that persuade without being valid, arguing that most bad reasoning survives because its flaws have no familiar name to catch it by.

PaidIntermediate
Book1936

Introduction to Logic and to the Methodology of Deductive Sciences

Alfred Tarski

Sets out quantification theory and the axiomatic method as the shared foundation beneath every deductive science, from arithmetic to geometry.

PaidIntermediate
Book1826

Elements of Logic

Richard Whately

A systematic logic textbook whose treatment of fallacies of ambiguity, begging the question and irrelevant conclusion became the standard classification used in English-language logic teaching for a century.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Book1843

A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive

John Stuart Mill

Sets out canonical methods — agreement, difference, concomitant variation — for inferring causal laws from observed regularities, treating induction rather than deduction as the root of empirical knowledge.

about 27 hours to readlink checked 17 Sept 2026

In order written

350 BCE – 2021
  1. 350 BCEPrior AnalyticsAristotle
  2. 1826Elements of LogicRichard Whately
  3. 1870Elementary Lessons in LogicW. Stanley Jevons
  4. 1879BegriffsschriftGottlob Frege
  5. 1881Symbolic LogicJohn Venn
  6. 1886The Game of LogicLewis Carroll
  7. 1896Symbolic LogicLewis Carroll
  8. 1903The Principles of MathematicsBertrand Russell
  9. 1918A Survey of Symbolic LogicC. I. Lewis
  10. 1930Straight and Crooked ThinkingRobert H. Thouless
  11. 1936Introduction to Logic and to the Methodology of Deductive SciencesAlfred Tarski
  12. 1956Intuitionism: An IntroductionArend Heyting
  13. 1996Paraconsistent LogicGraham Priest, Koji Tanaka & Zach Weber
  14. 2021Argument and ArgumentationCatarina Dutilh Novaes

Elsewhere in Philosophy