Project Sherlock

Philosophy

Aesthetics

Art, beauty and judgement — what makes a judgement of taste more than a preference, and whether art can be morally assessed.

10 topics · 17 curated works

Topics

Reading in Aesthetics

17

A way in

  1. Start here

    No prior grounding assumed.

    Ion

    Plato · 380 BCE

    Argues, through a rhapsode who cannot explain his own skill, that poets do not compose from technical knowledge but from divine inspiration that…

    +2 more at this level

  2. Then

    Assumes you know the vocabulary.

    On the Sublime

    Longinus · 100

    Argues that sublimity in writing is not decoration but the imprint of a great mind, produced by grandeur of conception and intensity of feeling…

    +8 more at this level

  3. Go deeper

    Primary sources and full treatments.

    Critique of the Power of Judgment

    Immanuel Kant · 1790

    A judgement of beauty claims universal agreement without appeal to any concept or rule, resting instead on a free, purposive harmony between…

    +4 more at this level

12 of 17 works

Book380 BCE

Ion

Plato

Argues, through a rhapsode who cannot explain his own skill, that poets do not compose from technical knowledge but from divine inspiration that bypasses reason entirely.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Essay1889

The Decay of Lying

Oscar Wilde

Argues, in the form of a dialogue, that art does not imitate life but the reverse, and that art's obligation is to beauty and artifice rather than to moral usefulness or literal truth.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
Book1897

What Is Art?

Leo Tolstoy

Art's value lies entirely in how effectively it transmits a genuine feeling from the artist to the audience, which leads Tolstoy to dismiss most of the celebrated art of his own time, including much of his own fiction, as fraudulent.

about 5.5 hours to readlink checked 17 Sept 2026
Book100

On the Sublime

Longinus

Argues that sublimity in writing is not decoration but the imprint of a great mind, produced by grandeur of conception and intensity of feeling rather than by technique alone.

about 2 hours to readlink checked 17 Sept 2026
FreeIntermediate
Essay1757

Of the Standard of Taste

David Hume

Argues that although taste seems entirely subjective, some critics are genuinely better judges than others, and that their agreement, refined by practice and freedom from prejudice, sets a real standard.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
FreeIntermediate
Book1835

Introductory Lectures on Aesthetics

G. W. F. Hegel

Argues that art is one of the ways absolute spirit becomes conscious of itself, and traces its history through symbolic, classical and romantic forms as each becomes progressively less adequate to that task.

PaidIntermediate
Book1854

On the Musically Beautiful

Eduard Hanslick

Music's beauty lies in its own moving sonic forms alone, not in any feeling it supposedly represents or expresses, founding musical formalism against the emotion-centred aesthetics of the Romantic movement.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
FreeIntermediate
Book1878

Aesthetics

Eugène Véron

Argues that art is the expression of human emotion through whatever means a given art form allows, and rejects both formal beauty and moral usefulness as the true test of artistic value.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
FreeIntermediate
Book1896

The Sense of Beauty

George Santayana

Argues that beauty is not a property of objects but pleasure objectified — a subjective feeling that we mistakenly experience as though it belonged to the thing itself.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
FreeIntermediate
Essay1907

Sketch of a New Esthetic of Music

Ferruccio Busoni

Argues that notated composition and the tempered scale are only a provisional stage in music's history, and that music's real nature is a free art bound by nothing but the composer's ear.

link checked 17 Sept 2026
FreeIntermediate

In order written

380 BCE – 1946
  1. 380 BCEIonPlato
  2. 100On the SublimeLonginus
  3. 1835Introductory Lectures on AestheticsG. W. F. Hegel
  4. 1854On the Musically BeautifulEduard Hanslick
  5. 1878AestheticsEugène Véron
  6. 1889The Decay of LyingOscar Wilde
  7. 1892A History of AestheticBernard Bosanquet
  8. 1896The Sense of BeautyGeorge Santayana
  9. 1897What Is Art?Leo Tolstoy
  10. 1946The Intentional FallacyW. K. Wimsatt & Monroe Beardsley

Elsewhere in Philosophy